Global warming, sexual abuse topics of SBC resolutionscomment (0)
June 21, 2007
Southern Baptist Convention (SBC) messengers generated some heat during their annual meeting as they debated the government’s responsibility to address global warming.
They also stood by the SBC Resolutions Committee’s decision not to address how many people actually populate Southern Baptist churches.
Otherwise they quickly dispatched seven of eight proposed resolutions June 13.
The global warming resolution did not generate debate on its basic points: global temperatures have risen for decades, "scientific evidence does not support computer models of catastrophic human-
-induced global warming" and major steps to reduce greenhouse gases would unfairly impact the world’s poorest people.
But messengers disagreed over the SBC Resolutions Committee’s call for the government to do something about climate change.
The committee’s proposal encouraged "continued government funding to find definitive answers on the issue of human-induced global warming that are based on empirical facts and are free of ideology and partisanship." It also supported "economically responsible government initiatives and funding to locate and implement viable energy alternatives" that would reduce greenhouse gas emissions.
Bob Carpenter of Cedar Street Church Holt, Mich., proposed deleting the two sections of the resolution that called for government action.
"For 70 years, beginning with the Franklin Roosevelt administration, we’ve endured expansion of government," Carpenter said, calling government "part of the cause of the problem rather than the solution."
The government cannot provide simple solutions to problems, he contended, adding, "hundreds of millions of tax dollars already are being spent" by the government on global warming. He insisted private enterprise is a founding principle of the country. "We solve problems … when government stays out of the way."
"The (resolutions) committee does believe the government has a role to play," countered committee member Martha Lawley. The resolution acknowledges God’s sovereignty, as well as individual responsibility, and it is balanced, she said.
However, Wiley Drake, the convention’s second vice president and pastor of First Southern Baptist Church, Buena Park, Calif., claimed the disputed portions of the resolution undermine the SBC’s stand for separation of church and state. "This weakens this resolution, by asking the government to step in," he said.
"This is not a church-state issue," Lawley maintained. "The government does have a role to play" in dealing with global warming.
Although messengers voted to remove the sections calling for government involvement, Resolutions Committee Chairman Gerald Harris later told reporters the convention overwhelmingly supported the overall resolution.
"I felt messengers were enthusiastic in adopting the resolution," he said. "I saw very few hands against" final passage of the resolution.
SBC messengers also passed a child abuse resolution June 13 in which they expressed their "deep level of moral outrage and concern at any instance of child victimization" and recommended reporting child abuse "in a timely and forthright manner."
The resolution called for churches and convention organizations to perform criminal background checks on ministers, employees and volunteers, and it renounced individuals who commit child abuse and "individuals, churches or other religious bodies that cover up, ignore or otherwise contribute to or condone the abuse of children."
C.B. Scott, pastor of Westmont Baptist Church, Birmingham, submitted one of the original versions of the resolution. The resolution passed with no opposition.
The only extended debate besides the global warming issue featured a suggested resolution the committee declined to propose.
Tom Ascol, pastor of Grace Baptist Church, Cape Coral, Fla., noted he submitted a resolution on "integrity in church membership" that did not get past the committee.
While the convention’s annual survey claims SBC-affiliated churches are composed of 16.3 million members, only 6,138,776 of them attend a worship service in a typical week, Ascol said.
Southern Baptists should "repent of our failure to retain responsible church membership and our widespread failure to lovingly correct church members" when they lapse from regular church attendance, he added.
If the convention does not take seriously its responsibility to retain a regenerate church membership and to discipline members, then a call to repentance — the subject of an approved resolution — "is meaningless," he insisted.
Ascol’s proposal "infringed upon the honored principle of church autonomy," Harris responded. "The committee does not have authority to instruct churches on their membership."
Malcolm Yarnell, a professor of Southwestern Baptist Theological Seminary and a member of Birchman Baptist Church, both in Fort Worth, Texas, affirmed Ascol’s call for "regenerate church membership based on church discipline." But he noted the proposal was not broad enough, since it didn’t address issues such as believers’ baptism by immersion.
"When we say we are a convention of 16 million people, we will say, tongue in cheek, ‘The CIA and the FBI can’t find half of those,’" noted Doug Richey of Pisgah Baptist Church, Excelsior Springs, Mo. "It does affect us corporately as a convention. This is a problem, and it is time we take responsibility for it."
Ascol’s proposal failed to receive a two-thirds vote required to override the committee’s decision not to recommend the resolution.
The committee also declined to act on several suggestions on two topics that received intense discussion when messengers acted on motions — glossolalia, or the practice of "private prayer language," and the ability of the 2000 Baptist Faith and Message (BF&M) doctrinal statement to serve as a "guide" for SBC agencies and institutions.
Harris and Lawley said those topics did not meet the committee’s criteria for action.
"We did not feel the Resolutions Committee was the Supreme Court to address theology for the convention," Harris said. "We didn’t want to precipitate a debate."
Glossolalia and the BF&M are topics best suited to be handled by motions, not resolutions, Lawley added.
"Motions direct" convention entities to take actions, while "resolutions reflect" the messengers’ beliefs, she explained.
"Resolutions are intended to reflect consensus of Southern Baptists on issues, not lead the way," she said, adding glossolalia and the BF&M proposals did not fall within the committee’s purview. (Editor’s Network, ABP)
Other resolutions passed during the SBC annual meeting June 12–13:
• Hate crimes. While urging Americans to “avoid acts of hatred and violence toward homosexuals and transgendered people” and calling on Christians to love and show compassion for them, the resolution condemned the Local Law Enforcement Hate Crimes Prevention Act of 2007 for including those groups as protected classes.
• Racism. Marking the 150th anniversary of the U.S. Supreme Court’s Dred Scott Decision — which declared African-Americans “had no rights which the white man was bound to respect” — the resolution affirmed SBC's repudiation of racism.
• Pastors, culture and civic duty. The resolution called on pastors to preach on moral issues and to lead congregations to influence the culture.
• Personal and corporate repentance. Citing Scriptures that condemn vindictiveness, bitterness, slander, sexual immorality and “failure to obey God,” the resolution called for “all Southern Baptists to humble ourselves before God” and “embrace a spirit of repentance, pursue face-to-face reconciliation where necessary and enter into a time of fasting and prayer for the lost.”
• Cooperative giving. A resolution expressed gratitude for the faithful support of the Cooperative Program, the SBC's unified giving plan.
• Appreciation. Messengers thanked God and those in the San Antonio area and others who helped with the annual meeting.